• 12605 Ulmerton Rd. Largo, FL 33774
  • 1-800-982-0398



About Our Agents


Michael D. McArthur

Michael McArthur has been with the agency since 1996 and now serves as its President. With over 30 years of expertise in professional liability insurance, he is known for his unmatched knowledge and hands-on approach. Michael is dedicated to ensuring every client feels confident that their practice and profession are fully protected. Under his leadership, the agency has built lasting relationships with providers nationwide by delivering tailored coverage and a truly personal client experience. Above all, Michael values integrity and trust, which remain at the heart of everything he and his team provide.



Todd Stacy
Todd Stacy brings more than 30 years of experience in the insurance industry, with a strong background in Property and Casualty before joining McArthur Insurance in 2012. His deep industry knowledge and practical expertise make him a trusted resource for clients navigating today’s complex insurance landscape. At McArthur Insurance, Todd plays a key role in developing tailored solutions that protect practices and give providers peace of mind. He is known for his approachable style, problem-solving ability, and commitment to delivering exceptional service. Todd takes pride in helping clients feel confident that their coverage is comprehensive and reliable, while building lasting relationships based on trust and transparency.



Scott Heintz

Scott Heintz brings extensive expertise in professional liability insurance, with a reputation for delivering guidance and solutions that are truly unmatched in the field. Known for his deep industry knowledge and client-focused approach, Scott takes pride in helping healthcare providers navigate the complexities of coverage with confidence and clarity. At McArthur Insurance, Scott is dedicated to building strong relationships and tailoring policies that meet the unique needs of each practice. His ability to simplify the insurance process while ensuring comprehensive protection has made him a trusted partner to clinics and providers nationwide. Scott’s commitment goes beyond coverage he is passionate about protecting the profession and giving clients the peace of mind they deserve.

Contact Us

McArthur Insurance Agency, Inc.

12605 Ulmerton Rd. Largo, FL 33774 Phone: 1-800-982-0398 Fax: 1-800-749-6445 Michael McArthur Extension 101
mikem@mcarthuragency.com
Todd Stacy Extension 103
todds@mcarthuragency.com
Amy Lanz Extension 102
alanz@mcarthuragency.com
Scott Heintz Extension 105
scotth@mcarthuragency.com

Contact with us

© 2021 McArthur Insurance Agency. Powered by MWD -